Wagner - Gotterdammerung
Varnay; Windgassen
Bayreuth Festival Chorus & Orchestra / Keilberth
Testament SBT41393 (4CD)

Release date December 2006

For many collectors, the revelation of Testament’s 1955 Bayreuth Ring will not be the singing of Varnay, Windgassen and Hotter, hugely impressive as they are, but the conducting of Joseph Keilberth. Critics have often dismissed him as a kapellmeister-ish figure, and while that may have been justified by some of his work as a concert music conductor, his recorded legacy reveals him to have been one of the most important opera conductors of the century. (Besides the 1955 Ring, you might check out his electrifying studio recording of Freischutz, the Walhall set of Oberon, the Bayreuth Flying Dutchman (a superb transfer of which is available on Testament) and Orfeo’s Vienna State Opera Arabella with Lisa della Casa. There are also two other Bayreuth Rings, both in decent sound.) Wieland Wagner chose him along-side Knappertsbusch, Clemens Krauss and Karajan to re-establish the reputation of Bayreuth after the war. By 1955, he had been conducting The Ring for twenty years and his interpretation was pretty settled; its pacing is almost identical to the 1953 performance (available on Andromeda). The principal difference between the new Testament set and the various Bayreuth Rings from this period is the spectacular, Decca-engineered sound. The pitch-black, sulphurous orchestration at the opening of Act II sounds bottomlessly deep, while few recordings of any period can match the ferocity of Hagen’s Vassals scene as caught here. Josef Greindl (the Hagen) could sometimes be a rather unimaginative singer, often relying on sheer bulk to see him through; inspired by Keilberth, he turns in a tremendous performance. Gustav Neidlinger made Alberich his own during the 1950s, and his incisively-sung study in malevolence has never been approached since. If anything, Windgassen’s Siegfried is even better than it had been two years earlier; the occasional rhythmic unsteadiness has almost disappeared, while he remains as vocally tireless as before. Lucky Bayreuth regulars of this period could compare and contrast Astrid Varnay’s fabulously-voiced Brunnhilde with Martha Modl’s very different but equally impressive interpretation. Varnay appeared on this occasion, and she is magnificent. Elsewhere we find such artists as Hermann Uhde (Gunther). Gré Brouwenstijn (Gutrune) and Maria von Ilosvay, who as Waltraute really makes sparks fly in her scene with Brunnhilde. The Norns are excellent (von Ilosvay doubles up as the First Norn); I’ve heard less fluttery Rhinemaidens, but then again I’ve heard much worse! The Bayreuth orchestra is never less than thrilling; they used to say that “Keilberth’s Rhine Journey is made by fast steamer”, and with good reason – it goes like the clappers! The Funeral March is raw and savage, with a prodigious-toned Principal Trumpet. The issue of Gotterdämmerung completes one of the two or three indispensable Rings on record, and arguably it is the finest of all.

Reviewed by Sandy Matheson